16

2026

-

11

Chromatic aberration correction in optical systems based on the center of gravity

Author:


Abstract: During the design of imaging optical systems, it is essential to correct for transverse chromatic aberration. For a given imaging beam, the center of the spot used in chromatic aberration calculations is not the intersection of the chief ray with the image plane; rather, it should be the “center of gravity” of all ray intersections within the blur spot—i.e., the centroid—which is determined by the distribution and number of rays traced. This paper describes how to compute transverse chromatic aberration based on the centroid and provides a macro written in ZEMAX to calculate the centroid coordinates at a reference wavelength, thereby facilitating better agreement between design results and actual performance.

Keywords: axial chromatic aberration; centroid; chief ray; optimization

Introduction

In early domestic software, the concept of the centroid was not used to describe off-axis geometric aberrations. Calculations of off-axis aberrations in a system were typically based on the chief ray, and transverse chromatic aberration was no exception. Consequently, this approach proved less accurate when characterizing certain system performance metrics. It should be clarified that the reference ray for geometric aberration calculations ought not to be the chief ray passing through the center of the system’s aperture stop, but rather the geometric central ray of the imaging beam. This distinction becomes particularly significant in the presence of vignetting; users of different optical design packages should be mindful of this difference. With the advent of the new century, the domestic optical design landscape underwent a near‑complete reshuffle, as advanced foreign optical design software gradually gained widespread adoption in China. The centroid concept has been effectively implemented in cutting‑edge programs such as ZEMAX and CODE V: both aberration analysis and design optimization can now be performed with respect to the centroid. This is especially important for systems where coma is relatively pronounced, as centroid‑based solutions more accurately reflect real‑world operating conditions.

1 The significance of the center of mass for calculating transverse chromatic aberration

During the design of imaging optical systems, controlling longitudinal chromatic aberration is an indispensable and critical step. It is easy to imagine how frustrating it would be if the final image exhibited colored fringes; for optical systems with high magnification, the control of longitudinal chromatic aberration becomes even more stringent. Depending on the characteristics of their products and their design experience, different companies place varying emphasis on the requirements for longitudinal chromatic aberration. However, they generally impose broad constraints on the residual errors among various operating wavelengths. Designers use these specifications to guide their optical designs, while user requirements in this regard are typically not quantified. We know that any quantitative metric varies in magnitude and significance depending on the chosen reference point. In general, off-axis aberrations of optical systems are evaluated relative to the chief ray, and this is especially true for longitudinal chromatic aberration, which is defined as the difference in image-space heights of the chief rays at various wavelengths for an off-axis field of view, measured relative to the chief ray of a reference wavelength. This definition has the advantages of low computational complexity, fast calculation, and results that depend solely on the chief rays being tracked, facilitating data exchange. However, the longitudinal chromatic aberration computed in this way may not accurately reflect real-world performance, nor is the designer’s goal merely to obtain a convenient design outcome; rather, the aim is to derive a metric that more comprehensively and effectively characterizes actual usage conditions. It follows that within the blur spot formed by an imaging beam, there must exist a reference point that most effectively characterizes the beam’s imaging properties. This point is not the intersection of the chief ray with the image plane, but rather the “center of gravity” of the entire blur spot—the so‑called centroid—which is determined by the distribution and number of traced rays. Evaluating chromatic aberration based on this centroid provides a more accurate description of real-world performance. Consequently, longitudinal chromatic aberration defined relative to the centroid becomes the subject of our investigation.

Unfortunately, almost all optical design software calculates transverse chromatic aberration using the chief ray at the reference wavelength as the reference point. For most optical systems, the coordinates of the chief ray and the centroid on the image plane differ; only along the optical axis do these two points coincide exactly. Under such circumstances, continuing to use the chief ray as the reference for evaluating transverse chromatic aberration may lead to results that do not fully match our expectations. This is one of the main reasons why some systems, despite exhibiting small calculated chromatic aberrations, still show relatively noticeable performance in actual use. If the concept of the centroid were incorporated into the analysis and calculation of transverse chromatic aberration during the design phase, it would significantly improve the agreement between the design predictions and the real-world performance.

2 Transverse Chromatic Aberration Based on the Principal Ray or Center of Gravity

As shown in Figure 1, YB, YG, and YR represent the image heights of the R, G, and B principal rays of an off-axis imaging beam on the image plane. With the reference wavelength being G, the lateral chromatic aberration with respect to the principal ray is:

R: YR-YGB: YB-YG

Clearly, the sagittal aberration of the chief ray is uniquely determined.

Author: Anonymous